The Nintendo 64, a beloved classic in the retro gaming world, still captures the imagination of gamers even decades after its release. With the rise of retro gaming and the ongoing hunt for nostalgia, it’s common to see questions like: “Is a Nintendo 64 worth $100 in today’s market?” Whether you’re a collector, a returning fan, or a newcomer to the world of cartridge-based consoles, here’s everything you need to know about the current value of the N64 and whether a $100 price tag makes sense.

The Situation: $100 for an N64 at a Local Game Store

Let’s say you walk into a local game store—one of those places that sells everything from movies to retro consoles. You ask about OG Xbox systems and Nintendo 64s, and while they don’t have the former, they do have a couple of N64s, each priced at $100. That includes the console, one controller, and all necessary cables. No games. No expansion pack.

This brings up the question: Is $100 too much?

Local Game Stores vs. Online Resellers

One of the first things to consider is the difference between buying from a brick-and-mortar store and buying online. PriceCharting, a popular resource for tracking video game values, lists a loose N64 console (meaning just the unit, no box or extras) at around $60. That’s typically the going rate on peer-to-peer marketplaces like eBay or Facebook Marketplace.

However, local stores often charge more. And there’s a reason for that:

Overhead Costs: Local stores have employees, rent, utilities, and other operational expenses that online sellers don’t.

Instant Gratification: You get the console right away, no waiting for shipping or worrying about damage in transit.

Customer Service: If something goes wrong, you can bring it back. That kind of buyer protection doesn’t exist on every online platform.

Supporting Local Businesses: You’re helping keep retro game shops alive, instead of feeding profits to a faceless reseller.

Nintendo 64 Condition is Everything

The value of a Nintendo 64 heavily depends on its condition. A $100 unit might feel overpriced if it’s yellowed, dirty, or has a wobbly controller stick. On the other hand, if the system is clean, works perfectly, and the included controller has a solid thumbstick (a common failure point), it starts to look like a more reasonable deal.

Here are some things to check:

Does the controller stick feel tight or is it loose? A loose joystick can ruin gameplay, especially in titles like Mario Party or GoldenEye 007.

Is the cartridge slot clean and fully functional?

Does the AV output work properly with your TV setup?

Are all power/AV cables original or decent quality replacements?

If everything checks out and the console is in good physical and working condition, the $100 price becomes a lot more justifiable.

What About the Expansion Pack?

The N64 Expansion Pack is a common point of confusion for buyers. It was used to increase the system’s RAM from 4MB to 8MB, which a few games required to run. However, only 2-3 games actually required the Expansion Pack (Donkey Kong 64, The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask, and Perfect Dark in full mode). And many copies of those games originally came bundled with the Expansion Pack.

If the N64 you’re eyeing doesn’t come with one, it’s not a dealbreaker—unless you’re specifically trying to play those titles. The Expansion Pack is easy enough to find online or in-store if needed later.

Making a Counter Offer

$100 might be pushing the high end, especially for a unit without any included games or accessories beyond the basics. If you’re on the fence, there’s no harm in making a counter-offer.

Pro tip: Try offering $80. It’s more than the online average, but still below the asking price. Many local stores are willing to negotiate, especially if you’re friendly and show genuine interest.

And if they won’t budge? Ask if they can throw in a cheap game, another controller, or even store credit. It’s always worth negotiating, and you might get more for your money than you expect.

The Verdict: Is $100 Worth It for an N64 in 2025?

Here’s the bottom line:

If the system is in good condition, with a tight controller stick and working cables, then $100 is a little high but not unreasonable.

If the store has a solid return policy or warranty, that’s added value you won’t get online.

You’re supporting a local business, which helps keep the retro game scene alive.

You get instant access to the console without the risks of online shipping or dealing with shady sellers.

However, if the system shows wear and tear, the controller stick is loose, and there’s no extra value included (like a game or warranty), then it may be worth walking away or negotiating.

Final Tips for Buying a Nintendo 64

Test Before You Buy: Always ask to see it in action. Bring a cartridge if needed.

Inspect the Controller: The joystick is notorious for wearing out.

Check for Expansion Pack: Look under the memory bay flap on the top front of the console.

Cleanliness is Key: A clean system has often been better maintained.

Know the Market: Use sites like PriceCharting, eBay sold listings, and local classifieds to understand the going rates.

Conclusion: Nostalgia Has a Price, But It Doesn’t Have to Break the Bank

The Nintendo 64 holds a special place in gaming history, and owning one today is like holding a piece of that history in your hands. $100 for a clean, functional N64 from a trustworthy local store isn’t a terrible deal, even if it’s slightly higher than the online market rate. You’re paying a premium for peace of mind, immediacy, and the ability to support a local business.

But if you’re patient, willing to shop around, or okay with the risks of online resale, you might save some money going the digital route.

So is a Nintendo 64 worth $100 in 2025?

It depends.

If you’re buying for nostalgia, convenience, and local support—yes. If you’re hunting for the best bargain possible, maybe not. The key is knowing what you value more: a good deal, or a good experience.